When it comes to training collars, Dogtra stands as one of the most respected brands in the market, known for its high-performance models that are perfect for professional dog trainers and avid dog owners alike. Among Dogtra’s wide range of training collars, the dogtra 1900s vs 280c stand out as two of the most popular options.
Both models offer a range of features that can help with training dogs of all temperaments and sizes. However, their specific features and performance capabilities make them better suited to different needs. To find the perfect fit, learn more about what size collar for a Bichon, ensuring your dog’s comfort and safety.
I will explore the key features, strengths, and differences between the Dogtra 1900S and the Dogtra 280C, examining their stimulation levels, range, design, battery life, waterproofing, and more. By the end of this guide, you will have a clear understanding of which collar is best suited for your specific dog training requirements.
My Personal Opinion
Having used both the Dogtra 1900S and the Dogtra 280C, I can confidently say that both models excel in their own right. The 1900S is an excellent choice for larger dogs or dogs that require higher stimulation levels for training, especially in wide open spaces or demanding training environments. It provides exceptional range and a durable design, making it a versatile tool for professional dog trainers or those who need long-distance control.
On the other hand, the Dogtra 280C is better suited for medium-sized dogs or those in need of a more compact and lightweight solution. While it may not offer the same range or power as the 1900S, it is more than adequate for basic obedience training and can comfortably handle a variety of training needs, including vibration and tone signals for non-correction communication.
Both collars offer reliable performance and are built to last, but the 1900S offers more power, range, and versatility for professional trainers working in more demanding situations, while the 280C serves as a solid, cost-effective choice for everyday dog owners and general training needs. Discover the ideal option by exploring what is the best collar material for a Bichon Frise to ensure your pet’s comfort and durability.
What is the Dogtra 1900S?
The Dogtra 1900S is a high-performance, single-dog training collar designed for serious dog trainers and enthusiast pet owners. With a focus on powerful stimulation and versatility, the 1900S is ideal for medium to large dogs, as well as dogs that may require stronger corrections for behavioral issues.
This collar is often preferred by professionals due to its advanced features and customizable settings. The American Staffordshire Terrier’s coat type is short, sleek, and easy to maintain with regular brushing.
Key Features of the Dogtra 1900S:
- Stimulation Levels: One of the standout features of the Dogtra 1900S is its 127 levels of continuous and momentary stimulation. This gives the trainer an immense amount of control over the strength of the correction, allowing for precise adjustments depending on the dog’s behavior and temperament. The collar is especially beneficial for stubborn or hard-to-train dogs, providing the ability to increase or decrease the level of stimulation as needed.
- Range: The 1900S boasts a range of up to 3/4 mile (1,200 yards), which makes it perfect for use in large outdoor spaces such as open fields, hiking trails, or large parks. This extended range allows for a greater distance between you and your dog, making it suitable for off-leash training or other long-distance activities. Whether you’re training in rural environments or just want the peace of mind that comes with controlling your dog at longer distances, the 1900S delivers excellent performance.
- Tone and Vibration: In addition to stimulation, the 1900S offers both tone and vibration settings. These features allow you to communicate with your dog in non-corrective ways. For instance, the tone feature can be used as a warning signal before applying stimulation, while the vibration feature is useful for getting your dog’s attention without the need for correction. These options offer a more humane approach to training, providing additional ways to communicate with your dog.
- Waterproof Rating: The Dogtra 1900S has an IPX9K waterproof rating, making it fully submersible and resistant to high-pressure water jets. This level of waterproofing ensures that the collar can withstand exposure to water in extreme conditions, such as heavy rain, mud, or even submersion in a body of water. This makes the collar an excellent choice for dogs that work in wet conditions or spend a lot of time outdoors in all types of weather.
- Rechargeable Battery: Powered by a Li-Polymer rechargeable battery, the 1900S provides up to 20 hours of continuous use on a full charge. This long battery life is particularly useful for extended training sessions and ensures that you won’t need to constantly recharge the collar. The battery charges quickly, allowing you to spend more time training and less time worrying about power levels.
- Ergonomic Design: The collar is designed to be compact, comfortable, and adjustable, making it suitable for dogs of various sizes. It features a slim profile that won’t weigh down your dog’s neck, and the adjustable strap ensures a snug fit that won’t slip off during training. The collar is also designed for durability, with high-quality materials that can withstand the wear and tear of intense training.
The Dogtra 1900S is a versatile and reliable training collar, providing everything a professional trainer or serious dog owner needs for high-performance training, particularly in open spaces.
What is the Dogtra 280C?
The Dogtra 280C is another exceptional dog training collar that is aimed at medium-sized dogs and designed for owners who need a reliable, compact solution for training. While it is not as powerful as the 1900S, the 280C still offers a broad range of features that make it perfect for obedience training, behavioral correction, and general off-leash control. The best collar size for an American Staffordshire Terrier ensures a comfortable and secure fit for your dog during walks and training.
Key Features of the Dogtra 280C:
- Stimulation Levels: Like the 1900S, the Dogtra 280C offers 127 levels of continuous and momentary stimulation. This ensures that the collar provides the same level of precision in control, giving you the ability to fine-tune your dog’s training. Although the 280C does not have the same high power as the 1900S, it still offers ample power for medium-sized dogs and can handle most obedience training and behavioral correction tasks.
- Range: The Dogtra 280C offers a range of up to 1/2 mile (800 yards), which is suitable for medium-sized yards, local parks, or short-distance walks. While this range is not as extensive as the 1900S, it still offers sufficient control for day-to-day training needs. The 280C is ideal for urban environments, smaller outdoor spaces, or when you’re working with your dog off-leash in a controlled setting.
- Tone and Vibration: The 280C also includes the tone and vibration features for non-correction communication. These options allow you to get your dog’s attention without using stimulation. The vibration setting, in particular, is a great way to alert your dog without causing any distress, especially if your dog responds well to non-corrective signals.
- Waterproof Rating: The Dogtra 280C has an IPX7 waterproof rating, meaning it can withstand immersion in water up to 1 meter for up to 30 minutes. While this is slightly less robust than the 1900S’s IPX9K rating, it is still adequate for everyday use, including training in rainy weather or wet environments.
- Rechargeable Battery: Like the 1900S, the 280C also features a rechargeable battery that provides up to 20 hours of use on a full charge. The battery life is more than sufficient for regular training sessions, and you won’t need to worry about the collar running out of power during important sessions.
- Compact Design: The 280C is known for its lightweight, ergonomic design, and comfortable fit. Weighing only 2.4 oz, it is particularly suitable for medium-sized dogs and is ideal for those who need a collar that won’t be bulky or uncomfortable for their dog to wear for extended periods. The slim profile ensures that the collar does not interfere with your dog’s movements during training.
While the Dogtra 280C is not as powerful or long-ranged as the 1900S, it is an excellent choice for owners of medium-sized dogs or those who need a more compact training collar for everyday use.
Dogtra 1900S vs 280C: Key Differences
Let’s take a look at the key differences between the Dogtra 1900S and the Dogtra 280C in terms of performance, features, and overall suitability for different types of dogs and training needs.
| Feature | Dogtra 1900S | Dogtra 280C |
| Stimulation Levels | 127 levels of continuous & momentary stimulation | 127 levels of continuous & momentary stimulation |
| Range | Up to 3/4 mile (1,200 yards) | Up to 1/2 mile (800 yards) |
| Waterproof Rating | IPX9K (submersible, high-pressure water) | IPX7 (immersible up to 1 meter) |
| Battery Life | 20 hours | 20 hours |
| Size & Weight | Collar weighs 5.7 oz, designed for large dogs | Collar weighs 2.4 oz, designed for medium dogs |
| Price | Higher price due to extended range and higher power | More affordable, great for basic obedience |
Key Differences Between Dogtra 1900S and 280C
Here’s a detailed comparison of the Dogtra 1900S vs 280C, focusing on the most important factors that will help you decide which collar is best suited for your training needs:
1. Range
- Dogtra 1900S: Offers a 1-mile range (1600 meters), making it suitable for training in large areas, such as wide-open fields, large yards, or hunting environments. If you’re training a dog that needs to roam, or if you require long-distance correction, the 1900S is an excellent choice.
- Dogtra 280C: Has a shorter 800-yard range (730 meters), which is still suitable for most training environments, particularly those around the house, local parks, or smaller outdoor areas. While the 280C’s range may not be as long as the 1900S, it’s still more than adequate for typical obedience training.
2. Stimulation Levels
- Dogtra 1900S: Comes with 127 stimulation levels, providing you with a wide range of adjustment to customize your dog’s training. This makes it ideal for handling more stubborn or aggressive dogs, especially those requiring significant corrections. The 1900S gives you more control, which is useful in a variety of challenging training scenarios.
- Dogtra 280C: Offers 100 stimulation levels, which is still more than enough for medium-sized dogs. While it has fewer levels than the 1900S, the 280C is still suitable for obedience training and offers precise control for less severe behavioral issues. It’s a great option for dogs that require moderate correction.
To find out the what size collar for an Affenpinscher, ensure you measure your dog’s neck correctly for a perfect fit.
3. Durability and Waterproof Rating
- Dogtra 1900S: The IPX9K waterproof rating means the 1900S can withstand high-pressure water from any direction, making it ideal for more extreme weather conditions or training around water. Whether you’re training your dog in the rain, snow, or in very wet conditions, the 1900S is built to handle it.
- Dogtra 280C: Has a lower waterproof rating of IPX7, meaning it can handle rain and brief immersion in water up to 1 meter deep for 30 minutes. While it’s still highly durable, it isn’t as resistant to high-pressure water or extreme weather conditions compared to the 1900S.
4. Size and Comfort
- Dogtra 1900S: The receiver unit weighs 5.3 ounces, making it a little heavier compared to the 280C. It is designed for larger dogs or dogs with thicker necks, providing a more robust build for dogs that need a more durable collar.
- Dogtra 280C: The receiver weighs 2.4 ounces, making it much lighter and more suitable for medium-sized dogs or those with more sensitive necks. It is also more comfortable for longer wear, particularly for dogs that don’t need such heavy-duty equipment.
5. Battery Life
- Both the Dogtra 1900S and Dogtra 280C offer up to 20 hours of battery life on a full charge. This is more than enough for multiple training sessions per day. Whether you’re using it for short or long sessions, you won’t have to worry about recharging the collar frequently. Both models provide long-lasting performance, ensuring your training won’t be interrupted.
6. Expandability
- Dogtra 1900S: Can train up to 3 dogs with additional collars. If you’re running a multi-dog household or need to train more than one dog at a time, the 1900S is a great option for managing multiple pets.
- Dogtra 280C: Can train up to 2 dogs with additional collars. This is still a great option for dog owners who have more than one dog, though it offers less expandability than the 1900S.
For a step-by-step guide on how to wear collar to an Affenpinscher, check out this detailed article to ensure a comfortable and secure fit for your dog.
7. Price
- Dogtra 1900S: The 1900S is generally more expensive due to its longer range, additional stimulation levels, and higher waterproof rating. It’s a professional-grade collar, designed for more demanding training situations and larger dogs.
- Dogtra 280C: The 280C is more affordable compared to the 1900S, making it a great option for owners of medium-sized dogs who require a reliable and effective training collar. It offers solid performance without the added features of the 1900S, which justifies its more affordable price point.
Dogtra 1900S vs 280C – Which One Should You Choose?
When deciding between the dogtra 1900s vs 280c, the choice depends largely on your dog’s size and training needs:
- If you have a larger dog, need a greater range, and require a collar that can handle stronger stimulation levels, the Dogtra 1900S is the better choice. It’s designed for serious trainers and those who need a more robust collar for demanding training situations.
- If you have a medium-sized dog and are looking for a lighter, more compact collar for obedience training, the Dogtra 280C offers excellent value. It’s a cost-effective solution that still provides all the essential features needed for day-to-day training.
Both collars offer impressive performance, so your decision will depend on the specific requirements of your training routine and the dog’s behavior. For guidance on choosing the right collar size for an Airedale puppy, check out this detailed guide.
