| Summary PetSafe offers a range of dog training collars designed to assist pet owners in correcting unwanted behaviors and reinforcing obedience. Two of their most popular models are the PetSafe Stubborn Dog vs Basic Dog Training Collar. While both serve similar functions, they cater to different types of dogs and training needs. |
The PetSafe Stubborn Dog Collar is specifically designed for large, strong-willed dogs that are difficult to train. It delivers stronger static corrections, making it ideal for breeds that require firmer guidance. In contrast, the PetSafe Basic Dog Training Collar is intended for small to medium-sized dogs with average temperaments. It offers gentler correction levels, which work well for general obedience training.
We will examine the key features, specifications, and overall performance of each collar to help you decide which one is best suited for your pet. Learn more about the unique double-layered coat of an Anatolian Shepherd and how to care for it effectively.
Overview: PetSafe Stubborn Dog vs Basic
Both PetSafe Stubborn Dog vs Basic training collars provide effective training solutions, but they are designed for different training intensities and dog temperaments.
Feature Comparisons: PetSafe Stubborn Dog vs Basic
Training Intensity and Stimulation Options
The PetSafe Stubborn Dog Collar is specifically engineered for large, strong-willed breeds that tend to ignore lower levels of static correction. It offers five levels of static stimulation, but these levels are significantly stronger than those found on the PetSafe Basic Dog Collar. In addition to static correction, the Stubborn Dog model includes a vibration mode, which is particularly beneficial for hearing-impaired dogs or those that respond better to tactile feedback.
In contrast, the PetSafe Basic Dog Training Collar is intended for small to medium-sized dogs that require a gentler training approach. It provides five levels of static correction, but the intensity of these levels is relatively mild to moderate. The Basic Collar does not include a vibration mode, as its static correction is typically sufficient for most dogs that are more responsive to lower-intensity training.
For owners of stubborn or strong-willed dogs, the PetSafe Stubborn Dog Collar is the better option, as it delivers more powerful static correction levels. However, if your dog is more sensitive and only requires minor behavioral corrections, the Basic Collar should be adequate. For insights on whether Pomeranians should wear a collar, including considerations for safety and alternatives, check out this informative article.
Range and Remote Effectiveness
A key differentiator between the two collars is their range. The PetSafe Stubborn Dog Collar provides a 1000-foot range, which translates to approximately 333 yards. This range allows greater flexibility for off-leash training in open fields, large backyards, or parks. The extended range is particularly beneficial for dogs that have a habit of running away or need consistent training reinforcement over larger distances.
On the other hand, the PetSafe Basic Dog Collar has a much shorter range of 300 feet, which equates to about 100 yards. This makes it suitable for small backyard training, indoor training, or environments where the dog does not require long-distance correction.
If you primarily train your dog in small, enclosed areas, the Basic Collar will suffice. However, for dog owners who need the flexibility to train in larger spaces or need a collar that maintains a reliable signal over a longer distance, the Stubborn Dog Collar is the superior choice.
Waterproofing and Durability
Waterproofing is another crucial factor when selecting a training collar, particularly for dogs that frequently play outdoors, swim, or live in areas with unpredictable weather.
The PetSafe Stubborn Dog Collar is fully waterproof and submersible, with an IPX7 rating. This means it can be submerged in water up to three feet deep for up to 30 minutes without sustaining damage. This level of durability is ideal for dogs that enjoy swimming, running through puddles, or training in wet conditions.
Conversely, the PetSafe Basic Collar is only water-resistant, meaning it can withstand light rain and occasional splashes but should not be submerged in water. If a dog wearing the Basic Collar jumps into a pool or gets caught in heavy rain, the collar may malfunction or suffer long-term damage. For a comprehensive guide on Which harness is ideal for a Pomeranian? including comfort and safety tips, check out this article.
For owners of water-loving dogs or those who frequently train outdoors in various weather conditions, the Stubborn Dog model is the more durable and reliable option. However, if your dog primarily stays indoors or in a dry environment, the Basic Collar’s water resistance should be sufficient.
Battery Life and Power Source
Battery life and the type of power source used in a training collar can impact its overall convenience and cost-effectiveness.
The PetSafe Stubborn Dog Collar uses a replaceable 9V battery, which lasts between 40 to 50 hours before needing replacement. The cost of replacement batteries ranges from $5 to $7 each, which can add up over time, especially with frequent use. The advantage of a replaceable battery is that you can carry a spare and swap it out immediately when needed, avoiding downtime between charges.
The PetSafe Basic Collar, on the other hand, features a rechargeable lithium-ion battery that lasts up to 40 hours per charge. While this duration is slightly shorter than that of the Stubborn Dog Collar, it eliminates the need for ongoing battery replacements, making it a more economical option in the long run. Charging the Basic Collar typically takes two to three hours, making it a convenient and environmentally friendly alternative.
For users who prefer the convenience of a rechargeable collar without having to purchase replacement batteries, the PetSafe Basic Collar is the better choice. However, for those who want the flexibility of replacing batteries without worrying about recharging, the Stubborn Dog Collar may be more suitable.
Multi-Dog Training Capability
For households with multiple dogs, the ability to train more than one dog simultaneously can be a crucial feature. Discover if the American Eskimo is a guard dog and learn about its suitability for protecting your home.
The PetSafe Stubborn Dog Collar is expandable for up to three dogs, meaning that with additional collar purchases, a single remote can be used to train multiple dogs at once. This feature is particularly beneficial for trainers working with multiple dogs or for households with several pets requiring behavioral correction.
In contrast, the PetSafe Basic Collar does not support multi-dog training. Each collar must be controlled by its own remote, limiting its effectiveness for users with multiple dogs.
If you own more than one dog and require a training collar system that can accommodate multiple pets, the Stubborn Dog model is the better choice. However, for single-dog households, the Basic Collar provides all necessary features without the need for multi-dog support.
Price and Value
Cost is an important factor when choosing between the PetSafe Stubborn Dog and the PetSafe Basic Collar, as both models fall into different price categories.
The PetSafe Basic Collar is the more budget-friendly option, typically ranging from $90 to $120. It provides an effective training solution for most pet owners who need a straightforward and reliable collar for general obedience training.
Given its lower price point, it is a cost-effective choice for those with small to medium-sized dogs that do not require high-intensity static correction. Learn about the size collar for an American Eskimo to ensure a perfect fit and comfort for your dog.
The PetSafe Stubborn Dog Collar, on the other hand, is priced between $140 and $180. While it is more expensive, the additional cost is justified by its stronger correction levels, increased range, full waterproofing, and multi-dog training capability. Owners who require a heavy-duty training collar for larger, more stubborn dogs will find the added investment worthwhile.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Which collar is better for a small dog?
The PetSafe Basic Collar is designed for dogs as small as 8 pounds, making it the better choice for small breeds. The Stubborn Dog Collar is meant for large dogs over 40 pounds and may be too strong for smaller breeds.
Is the Stubborn Dog Collar too strong for my dog?
If your dog is mildly stubborn or sensitive, the Basic Collar should be enough. However, if your dog frequently ignores lower correction levels, the Stubborn Dog Collar will provide the necessary intensity to get their attention.
Can I use the Stubborn Dog Collar on a deaf dog?
Yes, the vibration mode on the Stubborn Dog Collar makes it ideal for hearing-impaired dogs, providing an alternative to static correction. The Basic Collar does not have vibration mode.
Which collar lasts longer on a single charge?
The Stubborn Dog Collar lasts 40 to 50 hours per battery, while the Basic Collar lasts up to 40 hours per charge. However, since the Basic Collar is rechargeable, it saves money over time compared to the replaceable battery in the Stubborn Dog Collar.
Is the Basic Collar waterproof?
No, it is only water-resistant. The Stubborn Dog Collar is fully waterproof and submersible.
Verdict: Which One Should You Choose?
Choose PetSafe Stubborn Dog If:
- Your dog is strong-willed or large (40+ lbs)
- You need a long-range training collar (1000 feet)
- You want higher-intensity correction levels
- Your dog spends time in wet environments
- You need to train multiple dogs
Choose PetSafe Basic If:
- Your dog is small to medium-sized (8-55 lbs)
- You need a budget-friendly option
- You prefer a rechargeable battery
- You primarily train in a small area
Both collars offer excellent training solutions, but the right choice depends on your dog’s size, temperament, and training needs. If your dog is small and sensitive, the Basic Collar is perfect.
If your dog is stubborn and difficult to train, the Stubborn Dog Collar provides the necessary strength and range for effective training. Discover why Afghan Hound collars are wide by exploring the unique characteristics of this breed and how wide collars enhance their comfort and style.
